Everyone remembers the videotape of Andy Card whispering into President Bush’s ear on September 11th. It was at a Florida elementary school, and Card tells the President: “A second plane hit the second tower. America is under attack.” The President then looks into the distance. Some understood the look as a summoning of strength, others saw bewilderment. In any case, take a look at the next five minutes of the video, courtesy of Memory Hole. They don’t end the photo-op. The Secret Service doesn’t hustle the President out of the room. Ari Fleischer and Andy Card wait patiently. Remember what were you doing that day? The President sits there and does nothing.
The videotape doesn’t provide good context, which is unfortunate. This could be a clever edit job — for all we know, Card whispers to the President at the end of the video. It hardly matters, though. The image of the President and advisors finishing their self-serving photo-op while the country is being attacked and before the Pentagon was hit is heartbreaking. How does this match with the other accounts from that day? The President left the photo-op and proceeded to fly around the Southeast until the afternoon. There was confusion in the Situation Room as to whether planes could be shot down — eventually, Dick Cheney made the call. This video tells us that the President wasn’t rushed to safety. He wasn’t consulting with his aides. He was hanging out. Jokes about Cheney, Rove, et al being the real power behind the Presidency are common — after watching this, they’re not funny. They’re terrifying.
The Bush Video on September 11th by Gunnar Hellekson, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License.
I'm the Chief Technology Strategist for the Red Hat US Public Sector group, an open source and free culture advocate, a picky drinker, an amateur aesthete, and a dog enthusiast.
